AnimeSuki Forums

Y Ddraig Goch · 2019-09-05, 08:31

Yikes. o_o

Does it end amicably or is it still ongoing? Judging by the fact that is a bad end story, I would imagine Sakurai is using this story as her tragedy punching bag.

Cosmic Eagle · 2019-09-05, 09:03

It was a one-shot as far as I know. And yes, it wasn't a happy ending

shmaster · 2019-09-16, 19:14

Ahahaha, I was surfing around on Amazon and then I saw that Sakurai rip off novel on Narou actually got published under Dengeki label.
On top of that, Sakurai herself is hyping for this rip off.

This is too funny, I can't stop laughing.
I guess Sakurai is telling us she has finally stopped trying by approving this embarrassing rip off.

Cosmic Eagle · 2019-09-16, 23:57

Quote:

Originally Posted by shmaster

Ahahaha, I was surfing around on Amazon and then I saw that Sakurai rip off novel on Narou actually got published under Dengeki label.
On top of that, Sakurai herself is hyping for this rip off.

This is too funny, I can stop laughing.
I guess Sakurai is telling us she has finally stopped trying by approving this embarrassing rip off.

Link to title?

shmaster · 2019-09-17, 00:51

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cosmic Eagle

Link to title?

https://ncode.syosetu.com/n5967eb/

Cosmic Eagle · 2019-09-17, 02:15

Welp, guess this is the interim title for now then.

And I think it's also under Kadokawa as a standard novel

dragon1412 · 2019-09-19, 09:12

How much did it rip off from the original btw

shmaster · 2019-09-20, 03:57

Quote:

Originally Posted by dragon1412

How much did it rip off from the original btw

The writing style resembles her.
At various moments you can tell he used certain words just to look like Sakurai.
It doesn't help that the words "喝采" and "素晴らしき哉" are among the first thing you see when beginning reading.

The story is mostly about alchemists creating abominations in the dark side of London.
You just need to replace alchemists with "碩学" and you can tell where the story is going.

Though, no Outer Gods or WIC in this story.

dragon1412 · 2019-09-20, 07:05

I'd not really bother that much if it's just writing style though. As long as the content isn't too alike i'm fine with it. Then again, i have yet to read it yet so i can't comment on it. Probably will wait for the LN books to judge it, the editor might help a bit with that issues

shmaster · 2019-09-20, 11:19

The book is not under LN label.
And it was already on sale. It was published in July.

dragon1412 · 2019-09-20, 13:23

Quote:

Originally Posted by shmaster

The book is not under LN label.
And it was already on sale. It was published in July.

Thanks for the info, will be looking for it now

shmaster · 2019-09-20, 23:51

Quote:

Originally Posted by dragon1412

Thanks for the info, will be looking for it now

Link
https://www.amazon.co.jp/%E8%8B%B1%E...dp/4049123908/

dragon1412 · 2019-09-21, 02:47

Thanks you very much

Qliphoth Bacikal · 2020-02-04, 20:47

Does anyone here happen to know the canonicity of the novel's and doujins related to the Steampunk Series?

I got into the series for a while now and I've gotten a couple of books related to the series in the form of Karsheel(?) and Gahkthun's Novel Anthology, and I plan to get several more I could off of several item selling sites, if they still have any more in stock and legit, like Sona Nyl's Novel Refrain and one of those stories related to Ulthar.

Was wondering if there's any kind of novels or such that is or isn't canon to the series.

shmaster · 2020-02-04, 21:51

Quote:

Originally Posted by Qliphoth Bacikal

Does anyone here happen to know the canonicity of the novel's and doujins related to the Steampunk Series?

I got into the series for a while now and I've gotten a couple of books related to the series in the form of Karsheel(?) and Gahkthun's Novel Anthology, and I plan to get several more I could off of several item selling sites, if they still have any more in stock and legit, like Sona Nyl's Novel Refrain and one of those stories related to Ulthar.

Was wondering if there's any kind of novels or such that is or isn't canon to the series.

Yes, those are all cannon stories.

Cosmic Eagle · 2020-02-04, 22:08

Quote:

Originally Posted by Qliphoth Bacikal

Does anyone here happen to know the canonicity of the novel's and doujins related to the Steampunk Series?

I got into the series for a while now and I've gotten a couple of books related to the series in the form of Karsheel(?) and Gahkthun's Novel Anthology, and I plan to get several more I could off of several item selling sites, if they still have any more in stock and legit, like Sona Nyl's Novel Refrain and one of those stories related to Ulthar.

Was wondering if there's any kind of novels or such that is or isn't canon to the series.

Isn't the Ulthar one still in eternal production?

Qliphoth Bacikal · 2020-02-05, 00:07

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cosmic Eagle

Isn't the Ulthar one still in eternal production?

Last I recall, yeah -_-

There is one that's called "Door to the Moon World" or some such on those lines. I looked at Sakurai's Doujin Circle and I read the summary of it and got interested in maybe buying it off some site that apparently sells them?

I don't know. But the setting looks interesting. I'm just rather disappointed that it's not even an actual official thing yet...as in, a released work.

@shmaster: Ah cool. Thanks.

Cosmic Eagle · 2020-02-05, 00:37

There was supposed to be an anime. That is also now on eternal hiatus

shmaster · 2020-02-05, 00:59

Quote:

Originally Posted by Qliphoth Bacikal

There is one that's called "Door to the Moon World" or some such on those lines. I looked at Sakurai's Doujin Circle and I read the summary of it and got interested in maybe buying it off some site that apparently sells them?

It is a rough guide on what's on the moon in ancient times, when Great Old Ones still roams around in their divine vessel.

Qliphoth Bacikal · 2020-02-05, 01:13

@Cosmic Eagle: Yeah I looked it up a couple of times, and even saw some old tweets a few years ago.

Sad to hear so many of these...projects? Not being made, let alone released. A Steampunk anime would have been something I'd go to watch instantly, almost at the same time I (slightly off-topic here) went to watch the AL anime.

@shmaster: Great Old Ones? Heck yeah.

Gods or the like in Divine Vessels sounds like a dope concept. The same with Karsheel's Cyber Zombie's. I looked through the whole book and, depressing setting aside, I was really hooked into the new kinds of grotesque beings in the series like the Critters. But then we only had about a few which admittedly sucks.

2019-09-05, 09:03	Link #282
Cosmic Eagle 今宵の虎徹は血に飢えている Join Date: Jan 2009	It was a one-shot as far as I know. And yes, it wasn't a happy ending __________________

2019-09-16, 19:14	Link #283
shmaster オンドリャァァァ!!! Join Date: May 2009	Ahahaha, I was surfing around on Amazon and then I saw that Sakurai rip off novel on Narou actually got published under Dengeki label. On top of that, Sakurai herself is hyping for this rip off. This is too funny, I can't stop laughing. I guess Sakurai is telling us she has finally stopped trying by approving this embarrassing rip off. Last edited by shmaster; 2022-07-10 at 01:49.

2019-09-17, 02:15	Link #286
Cosmic Eagle 今宵の虎徹は血に飢えている Join Date: Jan 2009	Welp, guess this is the interim title for now then. And I think it's also under Kadokawa as a standard novel __________________

2020-02-05, 00:37	Link #298
Cosmic Eagle 今宵の虎徹は血に飢えている Join Date: Jan 2009	There was supposed to be an anime. That is also now on eternal hiatus __________________

2019-09-05, 08:31	Link #281
Y Ddraig Goch Chasing Echoes Join Date: Jul 2014	Yikes. o_o Does it end amicably or is it still ongoing? Judging by the fact that is a bad end story, I would imagine Sakurai is using this story as her tragedy punching bag.

2019-09-19, 09:12	Link #287
dragon1412 Senior Member Join Date: Apr 2011 Location: somewhere in Asia	How much did it rip off from the original btw

2019-09-20, 07:05	Link #289
dragon1412 Senior Member Join Date: Apr 2011 Location: somewhere in Asia	I'd not really bother that much if it's just writing style though. As long as the content isn't too alike i'm fine with it. Then again, i have yet to read it yet so i can't comment on it. Probably will wait for the LN books to judge it, the editor might help a bit with that issues

2019-09-20, 11:19	Link #290
shmaster オンドリャァァァ!!! Join Date: May 2009	The book is not under LN label. And it was already on sale. It was published in July.

2019-09-21, 02:47	Link #293
dragon1412 Senior Member Join Date: Apr 2011 Location: somewhere in Asia	Thanks you very much

2020-02-04, 20:47	Link #294
Qliphoth Bacikal Member Join Date: Feb 2020	Does anyone here happen to know the canonicity of the novel's and doujins related to the Steampunk Series? I got into the series for a while now and I've gotten a couple of books related to the series in the form of Karsheel(?) and Gahkthun's Novel Anthology, and I plan to get several more I could off of several item selling sites, if they still have any more in stock and legit, like Sona Nyl's Novel Refrain and one of those stories related to Ulthar. Was wondering if there's any kind of novels or such that is or isn't canon to the series.

2020-02-05, 01:13	Link #300
Qliphoth Bacikal Member Join Date: Feb 2020	@Cosmic Eagle: Yeah I looked it up a couple of times, and even saw some old tweets a few years ago. Sad to hear so many of these...projects? Not being made, let alone released. A Steampunk anime would have been something I'd go to watch instantly, almost at the same time I (slightly off-topic here) went to watch the AL anime. @shmaster: Great Old Ones? Heck yeah. Gods or the like in Divine Vessels sounds like a dope concept. The same with Karsheel's Cyber Zombie's. I looked through the whole book and, depressing setting aside, I was really hooked into the new kinds of grotesque beings in the series like the Critters. But then we only had about a few which admittedly sucks.