Mahouka Koukou no Rettousei LN - Q&A/Discussion about Families

[SoboSobo]

Originally Posted by hakazee

The roots of World War 3 to start is because there are food and energy shortage.

Also Tatsuya must solve those thing so Humanist will accept magician.


However no one in this novel think about how to stop the War.

Not to mention all Families in japan only think about power and weapon.
They never think magic can be use to save the world.

true, but so far the only large scale application of magic in society is the military or anything related to combat, intelligence, covert ops etc.

Off course the magic families in japan will focus on that in order not to lose their power and influence. And focusing on keeping their power and influence doesn't leave much room to research magic for other applications.
And besides research on that scale requires manpower, funding and government support.
And since there were no viable proof that magic can be used as power generation, or food production or any other major economical branch the government has chose to focus resources on more conventional technologies leaving magic research on a smaller scale.

Now tatsuya research is about finding a viable working principle for the gravity controlled fusion reactor.And the biggest obstacle as he stated is the ability to store magic sequences for later use. Hence his research in that relic he got from his step mother. IF he can crack that and store magic sequences that only needs 1 magician to activate and then runs on its own he solved the puzzle not to mention the million other application that technology can have.

And his goal is not to satisfy the Humanist his goal is to make magic a bigger part of society and giving magicians more choices in life then just the military.

[SinsI]

What's really strange about Mahouka is that they seem to form more-or-less traditional monogamous families.
If I were in charge of increasing magic might of a country, I would've made each prominent male magician have a few hundred commoner women as concubines. Even if magic genes are recessive, in 2-3 generations one would be able to get a massive explosion in the number of highly talented magicians.

[CatRules]

Originally Posted by SinsI

What's really strange about Mahouka is that they seem to form more-or-less traditional monogamous families.
If I were in charge of increasing magic might of a country, I would've made each prominent male magician have a few hundred commoner women as concubines. Even if magic genes are recessive, in 2-3 generations one would be able to get a massive explosion in the number of highly talented magicians.

I agree. Look at Shizuku's mother. They even forbid magician from marrying normal people. Is this racism?

[bakato]

Originally Posted by SinsI

What's really strange about Mahouka is that they seem to form more-or-less traditional monogamous families.
If I were in charge of increasing magic might of a country, I would've made each prominent male magician have a few hundred commoner women as concubines. Even if magic genes are recessive, in 2-3 generations one would be able to get a massive explosion in the number of highly talented magicians.

No politician would be willing to risk his but inflaming the masses just to get more magicians.

Originally Posted by CatRules

I agree. Look at Shizuku's mother. They even forbid magician from marrying normal people. Is this racism?

No. It's more like they want magicians to marry magicians to produce stronger magicians.

[kusabireika]

Originally Posted by bakato

No politician would be willing to risk his but inflaming the masses just to get more magicians.



No. It's more like they want magicians to marry magicians to produce stronger magicians.

I do wonder who is stronger bennio or shizuku?

[bakato]

Originally Posted by kusabireika

I do wonder who is stronger bennio or shizuku?

Probably Shizuku. It was stated that magical power was on the rise in successive generations.

[kusabireika]

Originally Posted by bakato

Probably Shizuku. It was stated that magical power was on the rise in successive generations.

true do you think that shizuku little brother will become magic engineer for her if tatsuya mentor him a bit or persevere in studying on how become a magic engineer?

[My Zodiac Aries]

Originally Posted by SinsI

What's really strange about Mahouka is that they seem to form more-or-less traditional monogamous families.
If I were in charge of increasing magic might of a country, I would've made each prominent male magician have a few hundred commoner women as concubines. Even if magic genes are recessive, in 2-3 generations one would be able to get a massive explosion in the number of highly talented magicians.

i concur. they should breed like rabbits.

[bakato]

Originally Posted by kusabireika

true do you think that shizuku little brother will become magic engineer for her if tatsuya mentor him a bit or persevere in studying on how become a magic engineer?

Probably since Tatsuya says so, but I wouldn't expect anything spectacular.

[guestuser]

Originally Posted by SinsI

What's really strange about Mahouka is that they seem to form more-or-less traditional monogamous families.
If I were in charge of increasing magic might of a country, I would've made each prominent male magician have a few hundred commoner women as concubines. Even if magic genes are recessive, in 2-3 generations one would be able to get a massive explosion in the number of highly talented magicians.

then how will they deal with those that dont want magic because not all people support magic in mahouka that is like asking for a revolt against the government

[My Zodiac Aries]

Originally Posted by guestuser

then how will they deal with those that dont want magic because not all people support magic in mahouka that is like asking for a revolt against the government

who don't want magic ? magician is superior human and they're use to protect the country.

[guestuser]

Originally Posted by My Zodiac Aries

who don't want magic ? magician is superior human and they're use to protect the country.

tell that to the people who hunted witches in Europe and their are religious people that believe in god gave them their natural ability not magic so it is not that of a good relationship and some are one step away before they condemn it with violence

[IceHism]

Originally Posted by My Zodiac Aries

who don't want magic ? magician is superior human and they're use to protect the country.

The Humanism movement of course. I think most of the USNA are humanists and they're spreading all over the place.

[My Zodiac Aries]

Originally Posted by guestuser

tell that to the people who hunted witches in Europe and their are religious people that believe in god gave them their natural ability not magic so it is not that of a good relationship and some are one step away before they condemn it with violence

modern magic is different with Witches, witches is Satanic.

Originally Posted by IceHism

The Humanism movement of course. I think most of the USNA are humanists and they're spreading all over the place.

humanist is terorist. they're foolish because they don't know who stop the Nuclear, actually they should thanks their Savior.

[zerozeronine]

Originally Posted by My Zodiac Aries

modern magic is different with Witches, witches is Satanic.



humanist is terorist. they're foolish because they don't know who stop the Nuclear, actually they should thanks their Savior.

Re-read the Visitor's arc lots of normal humans in the USNA are starting to be against magicians because of intel that humanist are leaking in the media.It's also spreading worldwide.

[CatRules]

Normal people can still be the one ruling because they outnumber magicians. But IF the number of mages become larger, they might lose control of mages and end up being the one ruled. It isn't much different than being conquered by other nations.


............. well who know, mages might take revenge for what normal people did to them during the first half of 21st century?


p.s. wait!!!! Shouldn't this be discussed in World and Setting Thread?

[My Zodiac Aries]

Originally Posted by zerozeronine

Re-read the Visitor's arc lots of normal humans in the USNA are starting to be against magicians because of intel that humanist are leaking in the media.It's also spreading worldwide.

The author make them look foolish, normal human can't stop Nuclear and the magician save them by stopping Nuclear bomb. Now they want to kill magician. Don't make sense.

[zerozeronine]

Originally Posted by My Zodiac Aries

The author make them look foolish, normal human can't stop Nuclear and the magician save them by stopping Nuclear bomb. Now they want to kill magician. Don't make sense.

I wouldn't say kill them outright,some would want to kill them,some would rather regulate them more especially use as weapons in the military.

[IceHism]

Originally Posted by My Zodiac Aries

The author make them look foolish, normal human can't stop Nuclear and the magician save them by stopping Nuclear bomb. Now they want to kill magician. Don't make sense.

Well if you read volume 8, the man did say magicians have an obligation to muggles. Of course the yotsuba are badass and was like "no we don't, fuck off"

[millie10468]

Am I the only one who's reminded of Coordinators and Naturals of the Gundam franhise when it comes to magicians and nonmagicians in this series? At this rate, isn't it only a matter of time until the magicians have to leave to create their own society? Though hopefully not into space