|
Senior Member
|
One List for the Tanks and my comments
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by 4chan GuP movie thread
Spoiler for From 4chan:
GuP Movie spoiler
The United High Schools (30 tanks)
8 Ooarai: Anglerfish, Turtle, Duck, Hippo, Rabbit, Mallard, Anteater, Leopon
6 Chihatan: Type 97(Nishi), Type 97(Hosomi), Type 97(Ikeda), Type 97-Kai(Tamada), Type 97-Kai(Nagura), Type 95(Fukuda)
4 Kuromorimine: Tiger I(Maho), Tiger II(Erika), Panther(Akaboshi), Panther(Continuous track chan)
4 Pravda: T-34/85(Katyusha), IS-2(Nonna), KV-2(Nina), T-34/85(Klara)
3 Saunders: M4 Sherman(Kay), Sherman Firefly(Naomi), M4A1(Alisa)
3 St. Gloriana: Churchill(Darjeelin, Orange Pekoe, Assam), Crusader(Rosehip), Mathilda(Rukuriri)
1 Anzio: Carro Veloce CV.33(Anchovy, Pepperoni, Carpaccio)
1 Continuation: BT-42(Mika, Aki, Mikko)
University All-Stars Team (30 tanks)
Pershing, Centurion, T28, Karl-Gerät
Top kill count
Alice (11 tanks)
|
Courtesy of http://boards.4chan.org/a/thread/133...vie#p133841862
Spoiler for My thoughts:
OK, some preliminary comments. Some other sources gave the All-Stars Chaffees as well, but I don't see them here. Oh well.
Anyway, Alice gets allocated 11 tanks of 29 (she didn't get the last tank).
I suppose the idea was to show us how utterly l33t Alice was, but this is not a good move. I know they have to give her more than the average, but allocating over a third to her is excessive. It inevitably shafts the rest of the team and in fact, other reviews I've read of the movie suggest that after Alice gets in her encirclement, which was broken by Rabbit Team before it could take real effect, the fight actually progressed in favor of the High School Team and then Alice decides to "show her stuff".
This decision also shafts *Alice* because instead of actually *commanding* like she's supposed to, apparently she placed most of her efforts into being a lone fighter. While such weaknesses are not unique to Alice (Miho and Maho are really also better single-tank fighters than commanders) ... Alice, wouldn't it be nice if you were different?
|